What Does a Rushed Decision Actually Cost You?

Owners rarely choose to rush the biggest decision of their working lives. The rush arrives on its own, through a new role, a health event, family pressure, or plain exhaustion, and the decision gets made under it. This article looks at what a rushed succession or sale decision actually costs, and how to buy back the time to make it well. It draws on Annie Duke's How to Decide, on Gary Klein's premortem method published in Harvard Business Review, on Dennis Carey and Dayton Ogden's CEO Succession, and on William Rothwell's work on preparing successors. It includes Dr. MaryJane Hanlon's own account of a sale made under pressure, and shows how the Right question of The Succession Filter™ protects an owner from deciding against a deadline.

Introduction

Nobody plans to rush the most important decision in their business, yet it happens all the time.

In my case, finding the right person to take over took far longer than I expected. I was particular, and I could not find the right fit. Meanwhile, I had taken on a demanding full-time role, the business still needed holding together every week, and personal pressures were mounting. In the end, the pressure made the decision for me. I chose someone I was not comfortable with, and I regret it to this day.

So today's question is a practical one. What does a rushed decision actually cost, and what can an owner do now to make sure it never has to be rushed?

Key Takeaways

•         The rush in an owner's biggest decision usually comes from outside the business: a new role, a health event, family pressure, or exhaustion.

•         Beyond the price, a rushed decision can cost the very outcome you were trying to protect.

•         Annie Duke's advice is to judge a decision by its process, not its outcome, and to plan for what could go wrong before deciding.

•         Gary Klein's premortem asks you to imagine the decision has already failed and explain why, which tends to surface more risks than asking what might go wrong.

•         The cure for a rushed decision is time, and time can only be bought early.

Where the Rush Comes From

Most owners imagine that they will choose when to leave. Often they do not.

Dennis Carey and Dayton Ogden, who spent their careers helping boards choose chief executives, open CEO Succession with what happens when there is no plan. Their most striking example is Texas Instruments, whose chief executive had told advisers the company needed no plan for the unexpected because he was in excellent health. A few months later he died suddenly while on a business trip, and the company was left without a ready successor.

That is a large company, but the lesson is the same at any size. The events that force a decision rarely give notice. Christopher Snider of the Exit Planning Institute groups them as the five Ds: divorce, disagreement, disability, death, and distress. A new opportunity belongs on the list too. Mine was a role I wanted, and it still left me deciding under pressure.

What the Rush Costs

The obvious cost is money: a lower price, or worse terms, because you could not afford to wait for a better offer. That cost is real, but it was not the one I regretted most.

The deeper cost is the outcome you were trying to protect. Owners who care about how their business continues are usually protecting their people, their customers, and their standards. A rushed decision puts all three in the hands of whoever happens to be available when time runs out. In my case, the business did not survive the transition.

There is also a quieter cost, which is what you never got to consider. William Rothwell's Effective Succession Planning describes the developmental gap: the distance between what a potential successor can do today and what the role will require. Closing that gap takes planned time. Rushed decisions skip it, which means even a good candidate may take over before they are ready.

Judge the Process, Not the Outcome

Annie Duke, a former professional poker player who now writes about decision-making, makes a point in How to Decide that every owner should hear. A good outcome does not prove a good decision, and a bad outcome does not prove a bad one. Luck plays a part in both. What you control is the quality of the process.

For a decision about succession or sale, a good process has a few features you can check:

•         You considered more than one option.

•         You gathered views from people who see things differently from you, rather than asking people to agree with a decision you have already made.

•         You thought through what could go wrong before committing.

•         You were not deciding against a deadline you could have avoided.

That last point is the one owners skip, and it undermines the other three.

Run a Premortem Before You Decide

One of the most useful tools for this comes from Gary Klein, who described the premortem in Harvard Business Review in 2007. Before a decision is final, you imagine that it is a year later and the decision has turned out badly. Then you write down every reason it might have failed.

Klein based the method on research by Deborah Mitchell, Jay Russo and Nancy Pennington into what they called prospective hindsight. Imagining that an outcome has already happened led people to come up with about 30% more reasons for it. That is a finding about generating more possible explanations, not proof that the reasons are more accurate, but for a decision as large as handing over a business, more reasons to check is exactly what you want.

For an owner, a premortem on a buyer or successor might sound like this: "It is a year after the handover, and the business is struggling. Why?" Possible answers include that the new owner changed how customers were treated, that key people left, that the transition was not explained well to customers, or that the owner disappeared too quickly. Each answer points to something you can check or negotiate before you sign.

Annie Duke recommends the same habit in How to Decide. Imagine the failure, imagine the success, and plan for both.

Buying Back the Time

If the cure for a rushed decision is time, the only place to find it is earlier. That means three things.

First, plan for your own future before you need to. I will be honest about my situation. I wanted to step away from carrying the business's finances every single week, and I knew I needed to secure my retirement. Both were good reasons. But I had not planned for them early enough to give myself room. As I put it now, no one is going to come and save you. Planning for retirement is each owner's own responsibility, and it has to be done early and stuck to.

Second, start the fit question years ahead. If you know who you would refuse but not who would fit, begin looking now, while you can watch people work.

Third, decide in advance what you will not compromise on, so that pressure cannot quietly rewrite your standards. Write your conditions down. When the pressure arrives, you will have something to hold on to.

Final Thoughts

A rushed decision can cost you on price. The larger loss is everything you were trying to protect, handed to whoever was available when time ran out.

Run a premortem on your own exit this week. Imagine it is a year after you have left and things have gone wrong, and write down why. Then start fixing the reasons while you still have time.

Book Your Free Practice Efficiency Call

If your premortem turned up reasons you are not sure how to fix, start with where the business depends on you today. A free 30-minute Practice Efficiency Call will show you where it depends on you and where it is losing time or money. https://calendly.com/drmjhanlon/the-hanlon-group-consultation




Previous
Previous

Would You Recognize Your Practice a Year After You Left?

Next
Next

Who Would You Refuse to Hand It To?