Who Would You Refuse to Hand It To?

Choosing who takes over a business involves two separate questions that owners tend to treat as one: who you would refuse, and who would actually fit. The first is a values question you can answer today. The second takes years, because fit can only be judged by watching someone work. A 2026 Harvard Business Review article by Samantha Hellauer and colleagues at ghSMART reports that founder handovers carry two to three times the risk of failure of other leadership transitions. Drawing on Gino Wickman's Traction, Jeffrey Sonnenfeld's The Hero's Farewell, and Ivan Lansberg's Succeeding Generations, this article explains how to write a refusal list from your core values, why that list is only half the work, and how the second question of The Succession Filter™, Right, keeps owners from confusing the two.

Introduction

Years before I sold my business, I knew exactly who I would never sell it to. There was one buyer in my market I knew I would never sell to, and I told him so directly. I held that line the whole way through.

What I did not have was the other half of the answer. I knew who I would refuse. I had never worked out who would actually fit, and when the time came, I did not have enough time to find out.

That gap is the subject of this week. Who you would refuse is a values question, and you can answer it this afternoon. Who would fit is a much harder question, and it needs time you will not have if you wait.

Key Takeaways

•         Choosing a successor or buyer involves two questions: who you would refuse, and who would fit.

•         The refusal question is about values and can be answered today. The fit question takes years of observation.

•         Harvard Business Review reports that founder handovers carry two to three times the risk of failure of other leadership transitions.

• Gino Wickman's Traction gives a practical test: choose one core value, and define the role by what the business will need next.

•         The Right question of The Succession Filter™ asks both halves and keeps owners from mistaking one for the other.

Why Founder Handovers Are Harder

Any change in leadership carries risk. A handover from a founder carries more. In a January 2026 Harvard Business Review article, Samantha Hellauer, Sanja Kos, Julie Vermoote, Sapna Sadarangani Werner and BJ Wright of the leadership consultancy ghSMART report that transitions away from a founder are two to three times more likely to end in failure or a drop in performance than other leadership transitions. The article attributes the figure to prior research without naming it here, so I treat it as a strong signal rather than a precise measure. The pattern it describes is familiar to anyone who has watched a founder try to step away.

Jeffrey Sonnenfeld's The Hero's Farewell, based on interviews with more than fifty retired chief executives, helps explain why. Leaders who build something tend to merge their identity with it. Leaving means giving up more than a job, so the decision about who comes next carries enormous weight, and it is easy to get stuck at the first, easier half of it.

The Question You Can Answer Today

The refusal question is about values. It asks: whose hands would undo what I built?

Most owners can answer it quickly, because they already know their non-negotiables. They know how they want customers treated, what standard of work they will not compromise on, and how they expect people to be led. A buyer or successor who would abandon those things is easy to rule out, at least in principle.

Gino Wickman's Traction, the book behind the Entrepreneurial Operating System, puts core values at the center of every people decision, and that includes the choice of a successor. The test is simple and demanding: the person who takes over should exemplify the business's core values, so that the culture continues after the founder has gone. Wickman's system pairs that with a second question about whether a person is in the right seat, meaning whether they have the skills and drive for the specific role.

You can write your refusal list this week. Write down the three to five values your business stands on. Then, for each one, write what a buyer or successor would have to do to violate it. That list is your refusal question answered.

Why the Refusal List Is Only Half the Work

Knowing who you would refuse feels like progress, and it is. It narrows the field, though, without filling it. Ruling out the wrong people does not identify the right one.

The fit question is harder for three reasons.

First, it is about the future. Traction advises defining the successor's role by what the business will need next, not by what it needed from you. Ivan Lansberg makes the same point in Succeeding Generations, his study of family business transitions: a systematic choice starts from where the business is heading, not from sentiment or habit. So before you can judge a person, you have to decide what the next chapter of the business needs.

Second, fit can only be judged over time. Values are easy to state in a conversation and hard to fake over months of real work. You learn how someone actually treats people, makes decisions, and handles pressure by watching them do it.

Third, the right person usually needs preparing. Lansberg describes succession as a process rather than an event. Wickman's own company followed that path: he and his co-founder spent years selecting and preparing the people who would take over before they stepped out of daily operations.

What Happened When I Had Only Half the Answer

In my own case, the refusal question was settled years in advance. The fit question arrived later, and it took longer than I expected. I was particular, and I could not find the right person.

Then the pressure built. I had taken on a demanding full-time role, and the business still needed holding together. Personal pressures were mounting as well. Eventually I had to decide, and I made a choice I was not comfortable with. The pressure overruled my judgment. I regret it to this day.

What I take from it is simple. I answered the easy question early and left the hard one until there was no time to answer it well.

Asking Both Questions in Time

The second question of The Succession Filter™ is Right: who would I refuse to hand this to, and who would actually fit? It deliberately asks both halves, because owners so often stop after the first.

A practical way to work through it:

1.      Write your refusal list from your core values this week.

2.      Write a short description of what the business will need from its next leader in five years, which may be different from what it needs from you now.

3.      List anyone, inside or outside the business, who might meet both lists. If the list is empty, that is useful information too.

4.      Plan how you would watch each candidate work over time: a project, a role, a partnership.

5.      Set yourself a date to revisit the list, well before you think you will need it.

What This Means in Your Practice

In dentistry, the refusal list is usually about patient care. You may refuse to hand your patients to someone who overtreats, who rushes the treatment conversation, or who would replace a long-serving team to cut costs. Write those down. They are your core values in clinical terms.

The fit list is where dentists most often run out of time. Whether it is an associate you hope will buy in or a buyer you are considering, you learn how they practice by watching them where the work happens: with a nervous patient, with your team on a hard day, and in how they present treatment and handle a complaint. That takes months, not a few dinners.

Start the fit list now, while you still have years to watch someone work in your operatory.

Final Thoughts

I knew who I would refuse long before I needed to. I did not know who would fit, and by the time I needed to know, I had run out of time to find out.

Write your refusal list this week. Then start the harder list, the one that names who could actually carry what you built, while you still have years to watch them work.

Book Your Free Practice Efficiency Call

If you are not sure what your business will need from its next leader, start with where it depends on you today. A free 30-minute Practice Efficiency Call is a good place to begin. https://calendly.com/drmjhanlon/the-hanlon-group-consultation

Sources & Further Reading

•         Samantha Hellauer, Sanja Kos, Julie Vermoote, Sapna Sadarangani Werner and BJ Wright, Leading After the Founder, Harvard Business Review, January/February 2026

•         Gino Wickman, Traction: Get a Grip on Your Business (BenBella Books)

•         Jeffrey Sonnenfeld, The Hero's Farewell: What Happens When CEOs Retire (Oxford University Press, 1988)

•         Ivan Lansberg, Succeeding Generations: Realizing the Dream of Families in Business (Harvard Business School Press, 1999)

Next
Next

Why Do So Few Owners Put an Associate in Their Own Chair?